Hutch Mansell (Bob Odenkirk) seems to be an ordinary family man. When two thieves break into his house one night and rob him, he gets the chance to overpower the burglars, but decides against it. For this action, Hutch earns a lot of ridicule from colleagues and neighbors. To make matters worse, the burglars have taken his daughter's favorite bracelet, whereupon Hutch goes in search of it. When he takes out all his frustration on a couple of hooligans in a bus fight that evening, he attracts the attention of a notorious mobster and it seems that Hutch is more than just a nobody.